HR: 16:50h
AN: U54A-03 INVITED     [Abstracts]
TI: Fantasy and Reality in the History of Weather and Climate Control
AU: * Fleming, J R
EM: jfleming@colby.edu
AF: Smithsonian Institution, Division of Space History, National Air and Space Museum, P.O. Box 37012, MRC 311, Washington, DC 20013-7012 United States
AB: This presentation examines the history of large-scale weather and climate engineering since 1840, with special reference to imaginative and speculative literature and with special relevance to ethical and policy issues. Ultimate control of the weather and climate embodies both our wildest fantasies and our greatest fears. Fantasy often informs reality (and vice-versa). NASA managers know this well, as do Trekkies. The best science fiction authors typically build from the current state of a field to construct futuristic scenarios that reveal and explore the human condition. Scientists as well often venture into flights of fancy. Though not widely documented, the fantasy-reality axis is also a prominent aspect of the history of the geosciences. James Espy's proposal in the 1840s to enhance precipitation by lighting huge fires, thus stimulating convective updrafts, preceded the widespread charlatanism of the rain-makers, or so-called "pluviculturalists," in the western U.S. One hundred years later, promising discoveries in "cloud seeding" by Irving Langmuir and his associates at the General Electric Corporation rapidly devolved into unsupportable proposals and questionable practices by military and commercial rain-makers seeking to control the weather. During the Cold War, Soviet engineers also promoted a chilling vision (to Westerners) of global climate control. Recently, rather immodest proposals to "fix" a climate system perceived to be out of control have received wide circulation. In 2003 the U.S. Pentagon released a report recommending that the government should "explore geo-engineering options that control the climate." In 2004 a symposium in Cambridge, England set out to "identify, debate, and evaluate" possible, but highly controversial options for the design and construction of engineering projects for the management and mitigation of global climate change. This talk will locate the history of weather and climate modification within a long tradition of imaginative and speculative literature involving "control" of nature. The goal is the articulation of a perspective fully informed by history and the initiation of a dialogue, stimulated by this approach, that uncovers otherwise hidden values, ethical implications, social tensions, and public apprehensions.
DE: 1600 GLOBAL CHANGE
DE: 1704 Atmospheric sciences
DE: 1803 Anthropogenic effects (4802, 4902)
DE: 6300 POLICY SCIENCES (7964)
DE: 6620 Science policy (0485)
SC: Union [U]
MN: Fall Meeting 2005