HR: 16:45h
AN: GP34A-04 [Abstracts]
TI: Paleomagnetism of ~635 Ma "Elatina Rhythmites," Reconsidered
AU: * Raub, T D
EM: timraub@caltech.edu
AF: Caltech, 1200 E. California Blvd.
Division of Geological and Planetary Science, Pasadena, CA 91125,
AU: Raub, T M
EM: tmdraub@caltech.edu
AF: Caltech, 1200 E. California Blvd.
Division of Geological and Planetary Science, Pasadena, CA 91125,
AB:
Extraordinary laminated sand-siltstone of South Australia's synglacial/deglacial Elatina Formation-equivalent at
Pichi Richi Pass is an iconic outcrop for paleomagnetists, paleoclimatologists, and astrophysicists. Cyclic-
bedded stacks of coarse/fine-grained doublets have been interpreted as rhythmites of semi-diurnal tidal origin in
a deep-water delta front environment. Cycle analysis has yielded estimates of Earth's paleorotation and
revolution periods and lunar distance. The reported 10 m (interpreted 60 year) record disagrees somewhat with
coeval and younger biological "sediment-clocks," and Williams (2000) argues that the sedimentological context
and extraordinary preservation of Elatina rhythmites makes that record preferable.
A paleomagnetic "synsedimentary fold" test on <8 cm amplitude antiforms from the Pichi Richi Pass rhythmites
confirmed low-latitude Neoproterozoic glaciation (Sumner et al., 1987) and inspired the formal "Snowball Earth"
hypothesis (Kirschvink, 1989). Repeated study of the Elatina rhythmites (Schmidt and Williams, 1995 and
citations therein) has documented NRM essentially equal to ChRM carried by detrital hematite, "locked-in"
synchronously with "deformation" of "antiforms" (i.e., within hours to days of deposition). "Synfolding" remanence
has been ascribed to superposition of slump-shear and DRM. Anomalously shallow inclination of rhythmites
(Sohl et al., 1999) could represent inadequate averaging of ca. 635 Ma geomagnetic secular variation.
New measurement of ten stratigraphic sections through rhythmite-bearing facies outside of Pichi Richi Pass
supports a distributary environment since rhythmites are expressed in multiple lithologies closely beneath
ultimate deglacial, Nuccaleena cap dolostone. At Pichi Richi Pass, a full section of rhythmites approx. 18 meters
thick is now documented, supporting a novel magnetostratigraphic collection of 130 samples. It is necessary to
re-examine the DRM interpretation of Elatina rhythmite magnetization, however, in light of new observations:
The structures previously considered "slump folds" are in fact sedimentary ripple crests. At Pichi Richi Pass,
rhythmite facies grade upward from undisturbed, planar lamination into disorganized dunes, then low-
wavelength, low-amplitude, linear-crested ripples, increasing steadily in wavelength and amplitude and climbing
upward in >50 cm packages to culminate in unambiguous ladderback ripples. This shallowing-upward
sequence reflects high sediment supply over 60 years and/or else significant sea level regression during
(possibly longer) rhythmite deposition. The exceptional character of climbing-ripple rhythmites can be explained
by pervasive microbial binding of sediment, in the anomalous mode characterizing many Ediacaran siliciclastic
environments.
Detrital magnetization seemingly should not around ripple crests. Either the interval of Snowball Earth
deglaciation was characterized by unusually low geomagnetic field strength, biasing magnetization fidelity, or
else Elatina rhythmites do not record DRM over a continuous 60-year timescale. This latter alternative may find
support in the original studies, which document considerable dispersion, unexpected for a VGP.
Kirschvink, 1992. in Schopf, J.W. and Klein, C., eds. The Proterozoic Biosphere, Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge, pp. 51-52.
Schmidt and Williams, 1995. Earth and Planetary Science Letters, v. 134, pp. 107-124.
Sohl, Christie-Blick, and Kent, 1999. Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 111, pp. 1120-1139.
Sumner, Kirschvink, and Runnegar, 1987. EOS, v. 68, pg. 1251.
Williams, 2000. Reviews of Geophysics, v. 38, pp. 37-59.
DE: 1520 Magnetostratigraphy
DE: 1521 Paleointensity
DE: 1522 Paleomagnetic secular variation
DE: 1533 Remagnetization
DE: 4926 Glacial
SC: Geomagnetism and Paleomagnetism [GP]
MN: 2007 Fall Meeting